Sunday, 29 July 2018

Detroit: An Abandoned City


Ever since I heard about the slowdown in Detroit's economy, I always wanted to visit the largest city in Michigan. And Aug 12, 2017 was the day when we rerouted our way through Detroit while travelling to Toronto, Canada from Iowa City, USA. Not because it was one of the most populated town in US but to observe the current status of the city. You can read more about the impact of World War I, Auto industry and racism clashes on Detroit. Decades ago, majority of its population moved to the suburbs leaving behind empty and deteriorating structures in downtown Detroit. 

In the past, city mayors tried to boost life in the downtown and spent millions. But when you walk through or drive in the area, you don't get the energetic vibes of being in an American city. Barely anyone is visible on the streets. Aging buildings and general loneliness in the surroundings makes one scared to even step out of the car (specially if you are aware about its local situation). While we were in Detroit, we drove around downtown, nearby rental areas and along the Rosa Parks street. Everywhere the scenery was hauntingly similar. 

Abandoned Buildings 

Detroit Downtown

Detroit Downtown

Abandoned Detroit

Abandoned Detroit

Abandoned Detroit

Abandoned Detroit

Abandoned Detroit

Abandoned Detroit

Downtown Experience 

Downtown skyline looked interesting from afar. But when we reached the heart of the downtown, it  gave really dark vibes. People were hardly seen on the streets and very less number of shops/businesses were in operation. It was a Saturday evening when trains were running empty. There is no doubt that it was an architecturally rich town but with time everything fell apart.

Detroit Downtown Skyline

Detroit Transit

An old building in downtown Detroit

An old building in downtown Detroit

Detroit Downtown

Detroit Downtown


Graffiti 

Graffiti is an integral part of the city. I don't consider graffiti as painted walls but there is a deep meaning behind every creation. And I noticed that in Detroit. From small pieces to large colourful drawings, there was a lot of graffiti. One such artistic interpretation of the city in the first pic of this blog is very moving.  

Mohammad Ali Graffiti in Detroit

Graffiti in downtown Detroit

Graffiti in downtown Detroit

Graffiti in downtown Detroit

Churches 

Churches are usually busy only on Sundays. As expected, our trip to the city on a Saturday did not reveal much activity in the religious buildings. Appearance of churches was clearly aligned in its architectural detail with other structures around the city. 

A church near downtown Detroit

Train Station 

Michigan Central Depot which is not operational for decades and has been sold to Ford Motor Co. for redevelopment. 

A church near downtown Detroit





Meet Ajinkya Shinde, a volunteer turned AAP Maharashtra Youth Wing Convenor


 
Ajinkya Shinde, AAP Maharashtra Youth Wing Convenor
Following blog is written by Abhijit Dipke who is social media coordinator with AAP Maharashtra team.  

In 2016 I met Ajinkya Shinde for the first time in Goa. He was a guy in his mid 20s who had just resigned from his high paying job and decided to work full-time for Aam Aadmi Party. After joining AAP, Ajinkya dedicated 1 year for Goa Elections. The party failed to open account in Goa Assembly Elections but Ajinkya continued his commitment for the party and started working with AAP Maharashtra Team. At the same time I also started helping him in party related activities.  

Kisan Sammelan: In Sept 2017, AAP Maharashtra Team was organising Kisan Sammelan. A successful event required presence of farmers from different parts of Maharashtra. To make this happen, Ajinkya visited every district of Maharashtra and held meetings with farmers. He almost travelled a distance of 13,000 km and turned the Kisan Sammelan into a very engaging and successful event. His dedication and determination was clearly visible when everyone was paying attention to the speakers on stage and Ajinkya was arranging and lifting chairs for the crowd. After giving his best for the event, he was seen standing in a corner of the last row, smiling on his achievement. 

Family and Career: Ajinkya is originally from Alibaugh, a coastal town in Maharashtra. His parents are farmers in Alibaug. He moved to Latur but his actual home is his car as he hardly stays at one place and has to travel frequently to different towns for party related work. The computer science graduate also worked for years in a Pune based international IT company. Before resigning from the company, he was working for the Aam Aadmi Party based on his availability as the Convenor of Pimpri Chinchwad. Now he is the Convener of AAP Maharashtra Youth Wing. 


AAP Maharashtra Team and Ajinkya Shinde, Youth Wing Leader
Ajikya Shinde with AAP Maharashtra Team 
When asked how he made up his mind to quit the job and join AAP as a full time member, he replied: 
There were times when I couldn’t sleep at night. I was confused, I had to work for this movement (AAP) which is our only chance to change the system but I had a job too and with that job I couldn’t give enough to the party. And this was creating a great dilemma for me. I had to choose one because I couldn’t have managed both simultaneously and hence I decided to quit the Job. I am more concentrated on AAP and I am free to move from one place to another. I am much more happy.

He actually meant the word “happy”. The emotion was clearly visible on his face. 

Hunger Strike: In 2015 Latur was facing one of the most horrifying droughts. Residents had no water to drink and authorities were busy in their routine. Ajinkya Shinde engaged the local youth and sat on chain hunger strike against the water crisis in Latur. The strike continued for 14 days and at the end authorities agreed to provide water supply on a daily basis. 

The Change: As a staunch supporter of AAP, Ajinkya is focused on the ultimate goal of changing the age old system. Once I visited a shop with Ajinkya. The owner asked Ajinkya about what was going on his life to which Ajinkya replied: "I don’t have a job and I am a full time volunteer of AAP". The owner smirked and said, "Why would anyone take such a decision of giving up their personal life and job?". Ajinkya replied, “Doing something for the society and working for CHANGE gives me satisfaction. No other job could have done that". 

The Meeting: Earlier this year, we called a meeting in Pune and asked Ajinkya to join. He promptly agreed and joined the meeting little late. When asked what took him so long, he said that he got to the meeting venue from Mumbai via train which was over crowded. This was because he parked his car in Mumbai which ran out of fuel and Ajinkya had only ₹300 at that time. With that much money he could not get enough fuel for the car to travel from Mumbai to Pune, so he took the train. We offered him financial help on many occasions and every time he denied the help.

Raghav Chadha and Ajinkya Shinde, AAP Maharashtra,
Ajinkya Shinde with AAP Spokesperson Raghav Chadha 
Whether he is short on money or has to sleep at petrol pumps or on the floors of party office, Ajinkya is always full of energy on the next morning. Members/Volunteers like Ajinkya always keep us in motion and inspire many others. 

Author Abhijit Dipke (twitter @aaptimist_) is the Social Media coordinator of AAP Maharashtra. He works closely with Ajinkya Shinde. You can connect with Ajinkya Shinde or send your questions related to AAP Maharashtra Youth Wing to his Facebook profile. You can also follow him on Twitter @AjinkyaShinde18

Read More: AAP Volunteer Charanjeet Singh  
AAP Volunteer since day 1: Aniket Saxena 

Do not want to miss stories on AAP volunteers? Please enter your email address:


Delivered by FeedBurner


Thursday, 26 July 2018

1 Crore Compensation Policy: Respecting Sacrifice and Bravery of Martyrs

In a press conference on July 24, Delhi CM Arvind Kejriwal briefed media on two important decisions taken by the cabinet. 1) Decision to re-launch Rs 1 crore compensation policy and 2) Plan to increase income of Delhi farmers 3-5 times. More details about farmer incomes will be discussed in future blogs. This blog is focused on the Rs 1 crore compensation policy.

It is brutally true that money can't fill the void created due to the loss of someone's life but it can bring financial stability for the family who lost their loved one. Whether a loss of life happens in the army, police or any other security forces, government of NCT Delhi will compensate Rs 1 crore if a life is sacrificed on duty. Delhi govt announced this policy in 2013 but it was discontinued due to political clashes in the union territory. Since SC restored the power of Delhi govt in its judgement on July 4th, AAP govt brought back the Rs 1 crore compensation policy.

The compensation of Rs 1 Crore is the highest compensation ever by any state government in India. Here is a timeline of the compensation policy announcement by Delhi govt.

2013: Delhi govt under AAP announced Rs 1 crore as compensation to the kin of police constable who lost his life fighting against liquor mafia. Despite the acidic relations that Delhi govt has with Delhi Police due to the complicated power structure and the bitter attitude of Delhi police against Arvind Kejriwal govt, AAP govt rewarded the family by recognizing and respecting bravery of the constable. 

2014: AAP govt introduced Rs 1 crore compensation policy. Later on Feb 14th, Arvind Kejriwal resigned after 49 days of governance.

2015: AAP came back into power in Delhi and passed the bill to make a standard policy of Rs 1 crore as compensation to families of personnel of uniformed forces killed on line of duty. According to this policy, Delhi-based families of personnel killed on duty but serving outside the city are also eligible. Personnel of Delhi Police, Defense personnel, Home Guards, Civil Defense, Marshals (who are deployed in buses for women security measures), Armed forces, Paramilitary forces etc. 


2016: Delhi govt amended the bill (in Feb 2016) to include families of defense personnel who lose their lives on account of operations, calamities and disaster. 

Here are the instances where Delhi govt has provided Rs 1 crore compensation to  martyr’s families.
  1. Dec 2013: Delhi govt announced Rs 1 Cr for Vinod Rai, a police constable who was killed by liquor mafia.
  2. Feb 2015: CM Arvind Kejriwal announced Rs 1 Cr for Cobra battalion head constable Narottam Das who sacrificed his life in a landmine blast in Gaya. A job was also offered to martyr Narottam’s wife. Delhi govt also promised to take care of educational expenses of his children.
  3. Dec 2015: Delhi govt gave Rs 1 crore to family of Constable Ram Kumar who lost his life in Karkardooma court firing incident in Dec, 2015. 
  4. Apr 2016: Delhi govt announced Rs 1 crore compensation to the family of slain NIA officer Tanzhil Ahmed.
  5. May 2016: Delhi govt provides Rs 1 crore as compensation to MM Khan – the NDMC law officer, who was murdered by a Hotel owner because he refused to take bribe for letting him off in an illegal construction. Check to the families of Tanzhil Ahmed and MM Khan were given in July.
  6. Aug 2016: Delhi govt announced Rs 1 Cr as compensation to the family of constable Anand Kumar who died fighting robbers in Shahbad.

After the above 6 compensations, the policy was discontinued when HC gave its judgement in Aug 2016. In its judgement, HC stated:

LG is the administrative head of National Capital Territory and AAP government’s contention that he is bound to act on the advice of Council of Ministers was "without substance"

AAP Govt challenged HC judgement in SC and on July 4th, 2018 SC stated in its judgement that:
LG does not have independent decision-making powers and is bound to act on the aid and advice of the Council of Ministers

According to Delhi Deputy Chief Minister, Manish Sisodia, Rs 1 crore as compensation is to pay homage for sacrifice and courage of martyrs. Whatever be the case, it is the responsibility of government to take care of families of those people in security forces who sacrificed their lives on duty.




Tuesday, 24 July 2018

Tuition fee refund by private schools in Delhi: Full story by Akshay Marathe


 
Since Aam Aadmi Party formed the government in Delhi, I have been continuously reading news articles about steps taken by AAP to force private schools to return excess tuition fees. However, this is the first time around that some actual progress has been made in this direction. Headlines such as "Delhi Government Asks 575 Schools to Refund Excess Fees with 9% Interest Rate", always bring a smile to my face. This change has stopped arbitrary increase of tuition fees by private schools. Couple of schools were disaffiliated and some other were taken over by Delhi govt after complaints were made against them. While reading the news in bits and bytes, I was curious about the steps that led to this revolution. Recently I had a chance to connect with Akshay Marathe, an AAP volunteer who worked with Ex Education Minister's Advisor Atishi Marlena. Akshay explained the backstory to these recent developments. 

How the Fight Started: The fight against tuition fee hike started somewhere around 1990s when a group of parents came together under the banner Delhi Abhibhavak Mahasangh. They approached the court to contest unacceptable tuition fee hikes by private schools which were not permitted by law. The law states that there are certain limitations on fee hike and the schools should submit their annual fee structure to the Director of Education (who is a government officer) before the beginning of the financial year. Schools violated the law and parents who approached Delhi High Court received a  favourable judgement. The reason behind parents approaching High Court is explained in the next few paragraphs. 

Violation of Guidelines: There are two bodies that govern schools in Delhi: 1) Delhi government (which enforces Delhi School Education Act (1973)) and 2) Delhi Development Authority (which signs the school allotment agreement). Whenever DDA allots land to a private school, they sign a lease agreement with a certain set of guidelines including a regulatory authority over the school. Schools are bound to follow the guidelines under the umbrella of Delhi School Education Act. In the past, when government authorities failed to implement these guidelines, problem of arbitrary increase in tuition fees began. With every pay commission, private schools started telling parents that school management needed to increase tuition fees to pay the salaries of teachers in accordance with the pay commission guidelines. They also highlighted extra expenses for constructing laboratories and other facilities at the beginning of each year. This seemed like a fair demand, but some schools started raising tuition fees to an unjustifiable extent. School management used the extra money left after payment of staff salaries to purchase land, villas, luxury cars etc.

Justice Duggal Committee: To protest, parents formed Delhi Abhibhavak Mahasangh and approached Delhi HC. High Court appointed the Justice Santosh Duggal Committee to solve the issue. The Directorate of Education and Govt of NCT accepted the Committee report in 1999 and it was government's responsibility to take action according to the committee report. However, the ruling government did not work on the report and the nexus between govt employees and private schools continued for years until Aam Aadmi Party came into power. All the regulations and notifications regarding tuition fee refund being implemented today are the results of Duggal Committee report submitted in 1999. The law says that if schools take fee for a certain purpose, its expenditure must also happen for the same purpose. A school cannot spend its excess tuition fee for anything else than the payment of staff salaries. Duggal Committee explicitly defined the term 'capital expenditure' which included things such as money spent on furniture, tables, fans, fixtures, etc.  

Justice Anil Dev Singh Committee: Delhi High Court made another committee in 2011 under Justice Anil Dev Singh which provided some more recommendations. The committee went through school financial reports and certified whether the school was entitled to raise tuition fee or not. In the 9th report from Justice Anil Dev Singh Committee submitted in Dec 2015, recommendations for a total of 1066 schools were presented. Some articles that I came across based on AAP government circulars: 


Bill Failed: Earlier, whenever there was a violation of law by school managements, the Government could take two actions: 1) they could either revoke the school license after which the school had to stop functioning or 2) the Government could take over the school management. Issue with the first action is that the ones who suffer the most would be children, parents and teachers. Second option is also very impractical due to the limited manpower available with the Delhi Education Department. In May 2015, Delhi Government introduced a bill to regulate fees of private schools in Delhi. The bill introduced varying degrees of punishments for specific violations by schools which would further empower the government to take strict action against violations of law by school managements. However this bill was rejected by the higher executives of central government. Unfortunately, BJP ruled central government has been doing this with every other bill proposed by AAP government. As of today, the bill is not implemented. 

The Fight: Every year when the Delhi Government issues a circular warning schools not to increase fees, these schools come together in a Union represented by famous lawyers such as Kapil Sibbal, Salman Khurshid etc. against the interests of parents. The reason behind the ability of private schools to increase tuition fees arbitrarily is the presence of a strong nexus between politicians, bureaucrats and private school managements. The politicians who were supposed to run government schools, are actually running their own private schools. As a result, it is in their own interests to run private schools and allow the condition of government schools to deteriorate so that the children move from government schools to private schools.

Parents have been fighting against this nexus between politicians and private schools for years but the recommendations were never implemented until AAP formed its government in Delhi. If any honest political party was elected in Delhi earlier then this situation could be improved and that is exactly what Aam Aadmi Party achieved after coming into power. With special status to NCT and different governing bodiesit has been a challenge for AAP to run the government as at each and every step they have to fight against the vested interests of politicians and some corrupt bureaucrats. 

Read More:🔻 
20 instances when Delhi govt proposals were rejected or approved with delay by LG office 
How it happened: ACB, FIR, RIL and the Power Tussle in Delhi 
The importance of two committees in Education and Healthcare formed by Delhi Govt 
10 images that you wont believe are from a government school 

Watch Full Video of Akshay Marathe: 


This blog is co-authored with Kshitij Vengurlekar. You can also connect with Akshay Marathe on Twitter for regular updates from Delhi Govt and to ask questions related to Delhi Education reforms. 

Want regular updates from this blog? Please enter your email address:


Delivered by FeedBurner


Friday, 20 July 2018

Cartoon from Pushpi: Punjab on drug war

एक बड़ी महामारी की तरफ बढ़ रहा पंजाब. |ये सरकारी आंकड़े हैं! वो भी एक क्षेत्र के, बाकी सारा पंजाब भी इसी आग में झुलस रहा है, असली संख्या बहुत ज्यादा है.

  • दाखा क्षेत्र के चिट्टे नशे से पीड़ित 63 नोजवानों को इलाज के लिए दाखिल करवाया गया, जिसमें से 55 काले पीलिये और 26 एड्स से पीड़ित निकले 
  • लुधियाना के नशा छुडाउ केंद्र में भर्ती हुए 34 लड़कों में से 14 एड्स और 13 काले पीलिये के शिकार निकले !!

इधर कैप्टन के सलाहकार कहते हैं कि सिरिंजों की बिक्री पर रोक लगा दो !! अगर रोक लगानी है तो नशे पर लगाओ, जिसके कारोबारियों को तुम्हारी सरकार पनाह दे रही है ! मौत की तरफ बढ़ रही पंजाब की जवानी को बचाने के लिए निकम्मी सरकारों पर भरोसा ना रखो, अगर बचना है तो खुद हिम्मत करो

Pushpi cartoon on drug war in Punjab
Cartoon from Pushpi Azad 

Tuesday, 17 July 2018

Meet AAP Research Cell Head and Women's Rights Activist, Arjun Joshi


 
In 2011, Arjun Joshi was merely 16 years old pursuing his high school education when India Against Corruption (IAC) movement began. This movement immediately caught the nerve of the nation. He joined it without delay and participated in IAC rallies which brought the entire country together. After many ups and downs, Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) was formed. At this point, Arjun was determined to change the system by being a part of the system. On graduating from high school, he enrolled for a Bachelor’s degree in Economics and continued supporting AAP. While living and studying in the Greater Kailash area and volunteering for AAP, Arjun was in contact with Saurabh Bhardwaj (present AAP MLA from Greater Kailash) and started volunteering in his office administration activities. He helped people to get ration cards who were previously unable to get one for 30 years and printed e-ration cards launched by the AAP Delhi government. The satisfaction of helping people in need kept Arjun attached to the work involved in Saurabh’s office. 

As an AAP volunteer, Arjun worked for election campaigns in 2014, 2015 assembly and 2017 Delhi MCD elections. He was also the campaign manager for MCD elections from Chirag Delhi ward. AAP candidate from this ward won the MCD elections when the whole election campaign was managed using a small amount of Rs 3-4 Lakhs. Other parties selected rich candidates who spent crores in the campaign while AAP volunteers crowdfunded the money and won elections in a close fight. Campaigning and social media engagements required research which lead to the formation of a think tank group (research team). Today Arjun leads AAP Research team and Internship programs

Research Team and Internship Programs: At present, the research team has more than 1500 people with participants from different parts of India. AAP is also offering internship programs lead by Arjun where people from India and abroad are joining and helping AAP. The internship programs focus mainly on public policy, data analytics, human resource management, social media marketing, content writing, data entry and legal advisory activities. These programs are an ongoing process where members can join for a certain amount of time, learn skills, help the AAP team and go back to their regular jobs. Sometimes, members change their mind and decide to dedicate their time entirely to working for AAP. Research work done by the research team and interns is used by: 1) AAP committees in drafting, 2) policies, party spokespersons addressing media, press conferences and TV debates, 3) MLAs for debates during assembly proceedings, and 4) social media teams. With the help of research work done by different teams, every MLA is equipped with proper knowledge even when the subject is out of their domain. 


AAP Research team with Saurabh Bhardwaj
AAP Research Team with MLA Saurabh Bhardwaj and Arjun Joshi 
Women Right Activist and the Book: Other than leading the research team and internship programs for AAP, Arjun Joshi is also a Women Rights Activist and works closely with Swati Maliwal (current Chairperson of Delhi Commission for Women). Due to various political and social reasons, rapes and harassments in the nation are getting out of control. In a recent report, India ranked World’s most dangerous place for women. After a 3 year old baby-girl was raped in Delhi, Swati Maliwal did not go home for more than a month and worked 24x7 from streets and hospitals fighting for women safety in Delhi. With the help of Swati Maliwal and NRI volunteer Prabhat Sharma, Arjun built a team and initiated the Rape Roke movement. This movement led the government to pass a law sentencing death penalty to child rapists. Currently Arjun is writing a book on the life of Swati Maliwal and Rape Roko movement which ended on International Women’s Day, 2018. 

While talking to NRI volunteers during a AAP ka Radio conference call, Arjun explained the current political scenario in Delhi by giving examples from Greater Kailash Area. Following paragraphs describe the ground realities behind the protest by Delhi Cabinet Minister in LG house, delay of projects approved by Delhi government, multiple authorities controlling Delhi, and an episode from the former PWD secretary Ashwani Kumar.  

The Protest over Power Tussle: After Delhi LG refused to meet Delhi CM and other cabinet ministers, who later sat on protest in LG residence, AAP organized a protest rally on June 16th, 2018 which was joined by +50,000 people. Whenever basic rights of people are denied, they have expressed their anger via protests. It wasn’t for the first time when AAP team protested while being in power in Delhi. This protest was huge and reminded of the IAC days when Arjun was just a 16 year old young Indian citizen. In the protest, people voiced their anger against central government which was (and still is) trying to rule-out elected government through LG office and MHA notifications.The protest and hunger strike from Delhi cabinet ministers was supported by leaders and ministers from other states as well. (Note: SC judgement on administrative powers in Delhi came later in early July, read here). 


AAP protested against central government
Arjun Joshi at the protest on Jun 16 
The Power Tussle Example worth Rs 600 Crore: As explained by Arjun using the example of water pipeline project in Greater Kailash constituency, water and sewage pipelines are 50-60 years old which are not only damaged at multiple places but are also not working properly. Previous governments neither maintained them nor put any effort to replace them. Delhi CM Arvind Kejriwal, also Water Minster allocated 600 crore rupees for water pipeline and sewage replacement/maintenance in Greater Kailash and other parts of Delhi. The 600 crore rupees required a sanction from LG office but the money did not reach the constituency level for project execution. This was because either it was blocked by the LG office or some other higher authorities (if approved by LG office) which are not accountable to Delhi Govt. At the end, people continue suffering with deteriorating conditions of water and sewage lines and developmental efforts from Delhi govt are wasted. 

Multiple Authorities in Delhi: There are three stakeholders in Delhi as a Union Territory: 1) Central Government, 2) State Government, and 3) MCD. Central govt rules NDMC (New Delhi Municipal Council), Anti-Corruption Bureau, LG Office and DDA via LG office. Delhi Govt also controls various ministries such as health, education, power, water etc. MCD is responsible for duties related to sewage, solid waste management, construction/maintenance of certain roads (which sums to 87% roads in Delhi), certain primary schools etc. When Delhi was being established as a Union Territory, services such as sewage system were distributed among MCD, DDA, PWD, DUSIB, DMRC etc. This process created multiple authorities responsible for the maintenance of these services. Sometimes a department e.g. PWD needs NOC from MCD to clean sewage system in a certain area but NOC is either delayed or not given. At other times, responsibility for sewage system maintenance is divided between two or multiple bodies, but cleaning duties lies with the MCD. This gives an excuse to accountable authorities who simply don’t work and get away with the statement that “not our duty because it is the responsibility of the other department”. This is a problem of governance and requires a better plan to resolve multiplicity in authorities. Another reason for the mess is respective political alignments. Various authorities don’t work together because they are ruled by different political parties. 

Petition and HC Judgement: : In 2005, petitioner BB Sharan from South Delhi filed a petition in Delhi HC seeking judgement over multiplicity authority in Delhi. It took 12 years for HC to recognize the issue and gave its judgement in 2017. For 12 years, HC kept calling various organizations, seeking their accountability and supporting evidences. The organizations kept avoiding or sought extension for next hearing which happened once in every 6 months. The 2017 order passed by HC recommended to form a coordination committee with members from all the governmental bodies with multiple authorities. Being the administrative head, the coordination committee will be setup by LG and the committee will be headed by PWD secretary (Ashwani Kumar). 

Ashwani Kumar Episode: IronicallyAshwani Kumar who had previously created many hurdles in the functioning of Delhi govt was now heading a coordination committee to solve the issue of multiplicity of authorities. E.g. Barah Pula Phase 3 project was proposed by Delhi Govt, passed by LG but stalled for 1.5 years because PWD Sec created obstructions in the construction and gave skeptical reviews about the project. Because of staggered projects, Delhi Govt constituted legislative committees (or petition committees) to monitor progress of a project in a particular constituency. The petition committees headed by MLAs started calling responsible officers to get an update and monitor the progress. One of the petition committee headed by Saurabh Bhardwaj called Ashwani Kumar in a court hearing when some discrepancies were found in the work completed by his department. Court ordered Ashwani Kumar to publish the drainage cleaning work on PWD and MCD websites. Next rainfall (after the data was made available online) lead to the suspicion that data was manipulated because drainage system cleaned by the department were found flooded and uncleaned. The petition committee was ready to send him to jail in a court hearing, but Ashwani Kumar went to media and stated that Arvind Kejriwal was not giving them any orders to solve these issues. He proposed that it was all Delhi govt’s fault which led to a breaking news criticizing Arvind Kejriwal among media houses and social media. Later PMO promoted Ashwani Kumar as the Chief Sec of Pondicherry. 

Watch full AAP Ka Radio video of Arjun Joshi 





You can connect with Arjun Joshi on Twitter @Arjun94Joshi and Facebook @arjun.joshi.568.


AAP USA chapter organizes a weekly conference call (AAP Ka Radio) every Sunday at noon 12:00PM EST. More details about the call and the guest can be found at @aapchat (https://twitter.com/aapchat).


Interested in receiving updates? Please enter your email address:


Delivered by FeedBurner

From "Narmada Putra" to "A Leader MP deserves"

Original article From "Narmada Putra" to "A Leader MP deserves" by Arvind Jha is available on Medium.com. More articles from Arvind Jha can be found on his medium.com profile 
 
As a third year student at the prestigious Indian Institute of Technology, Kanpur, he saw that a dalit basti near the college campus had kids who were loitering throughout the day and apparently did not go to school. It disturbed him and pricked his conscience enough that he went to the basti to find out why and then offered to teach the kids himself in the evenings. Over time he enlisted many of his friends to join his classes. As the students increased in number, he began wondering why there was no school for these kids. A little bit of digging showed that on paper a school was present and even 2 teachers allocated but in circa 1986 (and even today) there is hardly any accountability for govt teachers/infrastructure and indeed the entire political leadership — we keep electing these leaders even though they have failed generations of our children. He decided to meet the DIOS (District inspector of schools) and push for funds to improve the school. The DIOS was not used to kids from IIT pushing for schools (these were the brightest engineering students in India mind you) and after a few meetings, a princely sum of Rs. 25,000 /- was sanctioned to fix the school building, classroom and make sure the teachers start doing their job. For over 150 kids, Alok bhaiya was a god-send. 
As he ruminated on his learning from this social engineering, he noticed that the campus was having a large contingent of labourers from Bihar, engaged in the construction of new buildings and facilities within the campus. Their kids too did not seem to be getting any education /school to go to. When he started to talk to the labourers he found that they were also being denied their fair daily wage — they were signing on one amount and getting nearly half of it from the contractors. The only way to fix this, he decided, was the gandhian model (he had been reading up Gandhi, Aurobindo, Baba Amte, Osho as part of his interest in philosophy and spirituality). He asked a few friends to stage an “Dharna” at the campus to demand fair wages for the laborers. An agitation at the most premier engineering college of the country, which trains leaders of both global industry and Indian corporate sector was unheard of in 1987–88. But Alok was determined and convinced that this was the “right” thing to do. A few of his “wing-mates” (group of 12–15 boys who shared a hostel corridor/section) joined in and the college administration had to step in, audit the contractor and ensure full wages were paid to the construction workers. Alok had realized that social change needs struggle and that victory is sweet. 
As he graduated in Chemical engineering from IIT, Kanpur, the doors of corporate India, scholarships in US were open. Nearly all his bacthmates decided to take up jobs, higher studies, MBA and other career pursuits. Alok, was restless. There were questions he was dealing with — he felt he didn’t understand himself, didn’t understand his country and its people and wanted to explore a bit. He joined a social movement for fishermen in orissa; spent some time with tribals to understand their lifestyles; lived with slum dwellers to understand their poverty; went to Gandhi ashram at Wardha to see what he could learn / do there; travelled all across India for one year to understand himself and India better and finally decided to work at the Narmada Bachao Andolan cause he felt that the large dam based development model was over promising on economic returns and under estimating on cost of flooding, displacement and human suffering. He was also angry that the administration was bull-dozing thru without recourse to fair compensation, resettlement of those displaced in violation of the law of the land. 
What corporate India lost, Narmada Andolan gained — a volunteer who was smart, articulate, sensitive to people and their issues, sharp and logical in his approach, a master of organization and a natural leader of men and women. For the next 24 years, Alok Agarwal helped shape the Narmada Andolan through his leadership, scholarship, organizing skills, tactics & strategy to outwit the administration and thru grit, struggle and andolan for the benefit of the poorest people being affected by the large dams / flooding and displacement. He would use all forms of social protest, discussions, debate, andolan to struggle for fair and just compensation; adherence and compliance to the laws of the land wrt displacement of poor people; instill in the people awareness about their legal and human rights and above all constantly be on the lookout for policy that could help him argue his case better. 
His efforts and the efforts of the NBA led to significant outcomes — over 4000 cr in compensation paid to 5 lac plus people (though he feels this is less than 50% of what was due to them); a new land acquisition policy in India (the earlier law from British period was draconian and anti-people); a review of large dam based development model (many large dams were cancelled recently in agreement with the suggestions by the NBA) and above all a sense of respect and rights instilled in the tribals of Madhya Pradesh. No wonder they call him the “Narmada Putra” in those parts. 
One would imagine that such significant outcomes delivered to such large number of people would satisfy most folks. Not Alok. He was disturbed by the state apathy towards fair and legal rights of people; appalled by the state of the policing and attitude of officers towards the people who should be the most powerful in a democracy. He understood that while activism can raise an issue and solve it to certain extent but only being in power yourself can give you the power to effect ‘real change”. He also began to notice that MP lagged in human development index on all fronts featuring in bottom three of all states and a perennial BIMARU state. The metrics on education, malnutrition, child deaths, houses without electricity, without water supply, jobs, farmer deaths were so bad and the state of corruption so high that he made up his mind that he would dedicate the next phase of his life to fixing this. He decided to accept an offer from his old time friend and recently elected CM of Delhi, Arvind Kejriwal. 
Alok Agarwal joined Aam Aadmi Party in 2014 and contested the Lok Sabha election from Khandwa. He lost but learnt valuable lessons about organization for a political party, choosing people well, understanding issues that impact voters and managing a campaign. He also learnt about the utility of an election machinery, door to door cmapaigns, strong booth level organization in addition to value of public rallies, communication thru social and digital media and even press. 
Over the last 4 years, Alok has built Aam Aadmi Party into a fighting force and recognized 3rd alternative in MP. He is gunning for an organization that has 40000+ booth level supervisors and Aap-Ka-Saathi, a Mohalla level booth volunteer who manages relationships with 250–30 families at best. “The vote is delivered thru “election machinery” and I have learnt that only a robust booth level field organization, together with dedicated / passionate assembly, lok sabha and zone level managers can deliver the vote in an election” — he says. 
Along with the massive booth level election machinery, Alok is building the brains trust — a group of top notch professionals, many of them from his IIT/IIM networks, including many development sector professionals to help design development blueprints to fix MP’s chronic development and human index gaps. Teams are looking to create implementable, innovative and executable ideas / solutions that can be deployed at scale (MP is after all one of the largest states in the union) and that can achieve outcomes within 2–3 years. Teams of experts from all across the world are working on Education, Health, Electricity, Water, Job creation, Economic development and specially Farmer support. These ideas will find their way into the political manifesto and become the top promises / commitments made by AAP in MP, just like AAP’s 70-point manifesto in Delhi. 
AAP is also working on taking its significant successes in Delhi on Education transformation, innovations in healthcare and growth of state budget (from 32k cr to 53k cr) to people in MP to show them whats possible with an honest government that works with an honest intent. “To my mind, no other government has achieved so much in so little time as Delhi govt has demonstrated”, says Alok. “If we can successfully take stories of what people in Delhi are experiencing to the remotest corner of MP, we will be able to secure their support & vote. The people in MP have lost faith and hope in the politicians in these last 70 years — its our duty to step in and fix the badly damaged heart of India; to operate on the bad elements and create the mechanism to revive the state and the people. This is now my life’s next mission for whatever it takes” says the man who regularly tours across the state, with little/no sleep yet goes about his daily activities with a song on his lips and a prayer in his heart. 
I believe that Alok Agarwal represents the ideal politician for MP and even India today — capable, inclusive in his ideology, highly sensitive to people and their issues and with an educated and learning mind. Its time the people of MP chose a Karm-Yogi as their next leader, a leader who will use his skills, resources and ability to help change their conditions. Give honest development a chance. Give honest commitment a chance. Give your kids a chance. Hey MP, choose Alok Agarwal. 

Read More: Inside details of AAP Madhya Pradesh Campaign by Arvind Jha 

Monday, 16 July 2018

Committee on Petitions and payment strategies from the Govt of LG


While Aam Aadmi Party Delhi Govt is further seeking SC intervention in the implementation of its 4th July judgement, the capital has gained significant developments in the three year old power tussle that started during the first 49 days of AAP govt (when ACB registered FIR against RIL Chief Mukesh Ambani and two other Ministers). While officers related to the service department refused to follow SC judgement, Delhi food department referred the file related to doorstep delivery of ration to law department. Meanwhile the central government also decided to file a petition to review the 4th July judgement in SC. It seems as if LG/Central Govt don't want to lose control over the services even when HC slammed LG for not executing projects related to garbage management in Delhi and Centre controlled services sees no improvements or crackdown in corruption activities. Any idea proposed by Delhi Govt with the possibility of reducing corruption activities is either rejected, delayed or not implemented by the service department. As every authority in Delhi is looking at HC/SC for conflict resolution, it makes me feel that the judgement will not be delivered in this term like the previous case which took 2 years and all the visionary projects of Delhi Govt were stalled. 

Two Recent Developments in the News: Recently two articles surfaced which were talked about in the social media. 1) Delhi HC directs Delhi Chief Secretary (CS) Anshu Prakash to appear before assembly panel or face contempt action 2) Payment to lawyers, to appear for Delhi Govt in SC and HC, is stalled. You may not find any direct connection between the two headlines but both are connected in terms of "payments to lawyers". In the first case payment was approved and in the second it was stopped. Citing RTI reply from Dec 2017, AAP MLA Saurabh Bhardwaj briefed a press conference and provided the following information: 

Petition Committee and Unclean Drainage Systems: Unclean drainage system is a big issue in Delhi which causes flooding during monsoon season. Flooding leads to other problems related to traffic and health. Every city council promises to clean the drainage system before monsoon. However only some of them keep their promises and the rest forge the data. Councils even make false claims that the drainage system is clean, so floods won't occur. But fate becomes a reality with the first rain. Areas get flooded due to unclean drainage systems. Since the drains are reported cleaned in the beginning, there are only two possibilities: either drainage system is not efficient or council did not clean the drains properly. In order to find a suitable reason, Delhi assembly Petition Committee (PC) conducted an enquiry in 2017 with PC committee members, 2017 PWD Chief Secretary Ashwani Kumar, PWD Engineers and engineers from the local municipality where enquiry was being conducted. Around 100 different drainage systems were enquired based on the cleanliness report available with PWD and MCD. During the enquiry, drainage systems were found unclean while reports from PWD and MCD marked them clean. In the report submitted by PWD and MCD, both the agencies lied to PC,  Delhi assembly and Delhi HC. 

Petition Committee Recommendations: PC discovered huge corruption in the cleanliness of drainage systems. Uncleaned systems were marked as clean on papers and payment to contractor was released. After initial two visits, PWD CS refused to accompany the committee team which was conducting the enquiry. Photographs of unclean drainage system taken during the enquiry were shown to each officer (in a group as well as individually) of PWD and MCD departments. Committee also asked their opinion about the cleanliness which they agreed on that the drainage system is not clean. When individual officers were asked by PC to take action against responsible officers, each officer said in written that they are satisfied with the cleanliness and won't take any action against any officer. After that, PC submitted its report to Delhi assembly which was forwarded to Delhi Govt upon agreement in July 2017. Few recommendation made in the report were:
  1. Delhi CS (MM Kutty in 2017) to make sure that the directions mentioned in the report regarding cleanliness of drainage system are implemented on ground 
  2. Delhi CS to enquire reasons behind the assertions on paper that the drainage system is clean 
  3. Delhi CS to enquire about responsible person involved in corruption 
  4. Delhi CS should place a foolproof mechanism to verify each and every contract awarded and executed 
  5. Delhi CS should put modern and dynamic system to replace current obsolete mechanism of drainage and related activities 
  6. A verification mechanism with the help of local residents should also be established 
  7. Delhi CS should present the report in a month in Delhi Assembly  
RTI and Payment to Lawyers: After the instructions made in the report, Delhi CS did not perform their duties or submitted a report to Delhi assembly, instead they went to HC. In the HC, CS misrepresented the facts and as a result HC decided to make a stay on the report. In the process, an entire year got wasted and both Delhi CS and PWD CS did not complete any work. RTI reports revealed that LG office approved the Delhi and PWD CS's request to approach HC. Lawyers hired for the court proceedings were paid by Delhi Govt (LG as administrative head of Delhi). As such, the lawyers who fought to hide corruption in MCD and PWD departments were paid by Delhi Govt and they ultimately fought against Delhi Govt and Delhi assembly itself. In contrast, the lawyers who fought for Delhi Assembly and petition committees for 2 years are denied payment. Around 12 lawyers fought for Delhi Assembly in HC and SC to restore the power in Delhi assembly so that the responsible officers involved in corruption could be prosecuted and Delhi drainage system could be properly cleaned. 
 
Current Delhi CS (Anshu Prakash) also approached HC seeking exemption to report to petition committees. These committees exist to count the accountability of officers involved in various projects. Later, HC directed Delhi CS to appear before PC. In case of Anshu Prakash, details of approval to approach SC and payment to the lawyers are not available as yet. Saurabh Bhardwaj also stated that RTI queries are not being answered after Dec 2017 and around 35-40 RTI applications are pending in different departments. 


RTI Response (English, page 1) to the questions related to LG nod on CS and PWD Sec request to approach High Court and approve payment to highered lawyers
RTI Response (English, page 1) to the questions related to LG nod on CS and PWD Sec request to approach High Court and approve payment to highered lawyers 

RTI Response (English, page 2) to the questions related to LG nod on CS and PWD Sec request to approach High Court and approve payment to highered lawyers
RTI Response (English, page 2) to the questions related to LG nod on CS and PWD Sec request to approach High Court and approve payment to highered lawyers 

RTI Response (Hindi, page 1) to the questions related to LG nod on CS and PWD Sec request to approach High Court and approve payment to highered lawyers
RTI Response (Hindi, page 1) to the questions related to LG nod on CS and PWD Sec request to approach High Court and approve payment to highered lawyers 

RTI Response (Hindi, page 2) to the questions related to LG nod on CS and PWD Sec request to approach High Court and approve payment to highered lawyers
RTI Response (Hindi, page 2) to the questions related to LG nod on CS and PWD Sec request to approach High Court and approve payment to highered lawyers 

Watch full press conference of MLA Saurabh Bhardwaj.


Read more: How it happened? Timeline of power tussle in Delhi 

Missing regular updates? Enter your email address:


Delivered by FeedBurner